As the community continued to grow and the club gained momentum within the local community the decision was made to sell the club to its membership for $4.5 million. First board officers including Mr. Bill Grant Jr, Bob McCarty, Dan Call, and David Groeninger founded what is now Panther Creek Country Club on December 29,1993.
Throughout Panther Creeks history it has hosted numerous amateur and professional events beginning in 1992, with an event Mr. Klemm declared as the “Tournament of Champions” this inaugural event was hosted in October of 1992, and won by founding member Dale Blankenship. Later in 1993, Mr. Klemm announced the “First of America Challenge” would be played at Panther Creek in May of 1994, when tour players Orville Moody, Jim Colbert, Isao Aoki, Centralia native Tom Wargo and Chip Beck competed in a skin's game/scramble format for the entertainment of its members.